Ava Rakowski Rutherford is not lacking in one-of-a-kind businesses that keep the town lively. This specifically includes coffee shops where people can meet with friends, unwind alone, or plant themselves in a chair to get their life together. Bustling Park Avenue is replete with these caffeinated hubs, so we wanted to take you along for a coffee crawl. We’ll start on the north end of the street and work our way towards the quieter, residential side, staying hydrated and caffeinated along the way. Join The Bergen County Girl for a coffee crawl throughout Rutherford.
Caffé Roma | 140 Park Avenue, East Rutherford
This classic Italian spot has an old-school vibe. Caffe Roma is Caffé Roma at the top of Park Avenue (technically in East Rutherford, but who’s tracking that?). While some people live for fun latte flavors and creative combos, this spot is for someone who prioritizes quality coffee and quality service. This cafe has been serving the Rutherford community since 1979, so the team knows a thing or two about a good roast. Check out some of the quick bites, welcoming vibes, and outstanding cups of coffee.
Caffé Barbaro | 20 Park Avenue, Rutherford
Cross the train tracks to find Caffé Barbaro on the corner of Park and Ames. This company went from a family-run operation near Naples, Italy, to a cross-continental business, all while maintaining the high quality of the product. One of the best things about Caffé Barbardo is that you can take the fabulous flavor home with you by taking home a few different roasts and having that little taste of Italy, right in your kitchen.
Read More: The Best Diners in Bergen County, New Jersey
Ara Coffee | 6 Ames Avenue, Rutherford
This tiny spot just off Park Avenue is such a friendly spot to ask questions and get to know your coffee preferences. All of the beans are roasted in-house, so you can quite literally have your nose lead the way to your next brew. Plus, its Instagram features all their smiling customers; maybe you’re next!
Gainville Cafe | 17 Ames Avenue, Rutherford
Stay on that same little side street and make your way over to Gainville Cafe. This spot prides itself on reflecting the diverse cultural flavors of the area through the selection of food and beverages, and the ability to share resources with its community. Check out the global resource library, art exhibitions, and other workshops to connect with members of the community.
Rutherford Coffee Company | 70 Park Avenue, Rutherford
This spot is centrally located on your coffee crawl and one of the best places to kick up your feet. The coffee, pastries, and bites are on point, and the staff are some of the kindest people around. Whether you need to grind out some work for a few hours or chat with some friends on the couch, this place is an absolute must-visit.
Erie Bakery and Coffee | 10 Franklin Place, Rutherford
This one is for the sweet tooths among us. Tuck into this little side street just off Park to get your caffeine fix; the real star of the show, however, is the wide selection of baked goods. And, the team takes catering orders for holidays and other occasions, so you can share the Erie goodness with your friends and loved ones.
Steven’s Cafe | 106 Park Avenue, Rutherford
Get back to Park and continue south to make your way to Steven’s Cafe. This eatery and coffee shop is for the person who loves a sleek, modern feel with quality food and service. This place has you covered for a full breakfast spread of savory and sweet, with some outstanding beverage options to match.
Be Well Cafe | 6 Highland Cross, Rutherford
Be Well Cafe gives you a different cafe vibe than the other selections on this list. This location, slightly further from the hustle and bustle of Park Avenue, offers a wide selection of juices, smoothies, and wellness bowls. If you’re looking for a healthy fix after a crawl of coffee and sweet treats, you’ll find the plant-based options bright and refreshing.
See More: A Guide to the Coffee Shops in the Asbury Park Area
Follow @thebergencountygirl on Instagram for the latest Bergen County updates, sign up for our email list here that shares everything you missed each week, and check out our events calendar, which has over 30+ events weekly to peruse.
