Coniglio’s King of Pies has closed its Asbury Park location just over five months after opening at the Jersey Shore. Located at 649 Mattison Avenue, the pizzeria opened on June 12th, 2026, as an expansion of Coniglio’s Old Fashioned, based in Morristown. The restaurant brought pizza maker Nino Coniglio’s signature pies to downtown Asbury Park, initially operating with a limited menu and shorter hours. On November 18th, 2026, the team announced the closure via Instagram, thanking the Asbury community for its support since opening. Read on for what we know about Coniglio’s closure in Asbury Park.
The Closure Announcement
In its announcement, the team thanked the Asbury community for supporting the restaurant since its opening. The business described the closure as “a little pause” and indicated that there would be more news to come. A permanent shutdown has not been confirmed.
Read More: New Italian-Inspired Cafe, Cafe Scala, Opens in Freehold, NJ
The Jersey Shore Girl first reported on plans for Coniglio’s Jersey Shore expansion in December 2025. The Asbury Park location opened on June 12th, 2026, putting the November 18th closure announcement just over five months after its debut.
View this post on Instagram
The restaurant was an expansion of Coniglio’s Old Fashioned in Morristown. Owner Nino Coniglio is a 10-time world pizza champion and a winner of Food Network’s Chopped, according to the restaurant’s website.
See More: New Jersey Film Trail Is Officially Coming to the Garden State
When the Asbury Park spot opened, it began with a limited menu and shorter hours. Its opening lineup included the Brooklyn Round, Josephine’s Grandma, and Upside Down Sicilian pies.
Follow @thejerseyshoregirl_ on Instagram for the latest Jersey Shore updates, sign up for our weekly newsletter here that shares everything you missed each week, and check out our events calendar, which has over 40+ events weekly to peruse.

