Jessica Norton 
Online shopping has made it easy to forget how many everyday essentials are already sitting on shelves right here at the Jersey Shore. From beach gear and books to home goods, gifts, beauty products, and wellness staples, local shops are carrying the same kinds of items people often default to ordering on Amazon and other online retailers. There are so many simple, in-person alternatives that make last-minute runs quicker, more personal, and more impactful for the local economy. Each shop is a reminder that convenience doesn’t have to come from a warehouse when it’s already just down the street. Read on for ways to shop local and skip Amazon and other big-box stores at the Jersey Shore.
Asbury Park Art Club | 1100 Ocean Avenue, Asbury Park
If you need: Arts + crafts supplies
The “art supply thrift shop” inside Asbury Park Art Club is a creative, eco-friendly way to find rescued materials and DIY kits, keeping usable supplies out of landfills. The art thrift shop has paints, papers, glues, charms, scissors, and other crafting essentials, which makes it easy to find everything needed for projects in one place without having to order anything online.
Ben Franklin | 1205 Grand Central Avenue, Lavallette
If you need: Beach accessories, housewares, gifts, hardware, toys, and souvenirs
Ben Franklin in Lavallette has just about everything needed for a beach day or a quick household fix in one stop. The shop carries beach accessories like chairs, umbrellas, suntan lotion, and toys, along with housewares, hardware, gifts, souvenirs, and sporting goods. It’s the kind of place where last-minute beach essentials or forgotten items can be picked up right away without waiting for a delivery. The variety makes it just as useful for year-round locals as it is for visitors stocking up for a day on the sand.
Read More: LGBTQ+-Owned Businesses to Support at the Jersey Shore
Baja East Surf Shop | 2600 Bridge Avenue, Point Pleasant
If you need: Bathing suits, surf boards, boogie boards, clothes, shoes, and gifts
Baja East Surf Shop in Point Pleasant is a go-to stop for everything needed for a day at the beach or a season of surfing. The shop carries bathing suits, wetsuits, surfboards, boogie boards, clothing, shoes, and beach-ready gifts all in one place. Instead of scrolling through endless options online, everything can be tried on, sized correctly, and seen in person before buying. It’s especially helpful for finding gear that actually fits our local beach conditions and style.
Butler Pharmacy | 2301 Bridge Avenue, Point Pleasant
If you need: OTC medicine, gift wrap, cards, stationery, gifts, vitamins, and beauty supplies
Butler Pharmacy is a classic one-stop neighborhood shop that makes everyday errands a little easier. Beyond prescriptions, the store carries cards, gift wrap, stationery, gifts, vitamins, over-the-counter medications, and beauty products, just to name a few, covering a lot of the same basics people often order online. Whether it’s picking up a birthday card, a new bottle of nail polish, crutches because of a hurt foot, or some Benadryl for an allergic reaction, this shop has a large selection of essentials that are so easy to grab in person.
The Dune Market | 414 N Bay Avenue, Beach Haven
If you need: Home decor, books, self-care, gifts, and beach accessories
The Dune Market in Beach Haven is a thoughtfully curated boutique that makes it easy to find everyday essentials and coastal-inspired treasures in one place. The store carries home decor, books, self-care items, gifts, and beach accessories that feel intentionally selected rather than mass-produced. Instead of scrolling, everything can be seen in person and chosen based on quality, style, and feel. It’s a great stop for picking up a meaningful gift or refreshing a beach house with pieces that match the shore lifestyle.
The Flying Pig Market | 527 Bangs Avenue, Asbury Park
If you need: groceries, condiments, snacks, coffee, and desserts
The Flying Pig Market is a convenient neighborhood stop for groceries, pantry staples, and locally sourced treats. The shelves are stocked with snacks, condiments, coffee, desserts, and everyday grocery items, making it easy to pick up both necessities and a few fun finds. Instead of adding specialty foods and pantry items to an online order, shoppers can browse in person and discover new products along the way. It’s especially useful for grabbing ingredients for dinner, a host gift, or a last-minute dessert.
Main Avenue Galleria | 35 Pilgrim Pathway, Ocean Grove
If you need: Art supplies, frames, artwork, gifts
Main Avenue Galleria in Ocean Grove carries artwork, frames, art supplies, and unique gifts, making it an easy stop for everything from decorating a home to finding a thoughtful present. Seeing artwork and frames in person allows shoppers to appreciate the colors, textures, and craftsmanship in a way that photos simply can’t capture. The mix of local art and creative supplies also makes every visit feel a little different. Shopping here supports artists and a small business that has long been part of the Jersey Shore arts community.
Mercuriosities on Main | 39 Main Street, Farmingdale
If you need: Skincare products, gifts, herbal teas, and accessories
Mercuriosities on Main in Farmingdale is a whimsical shop filled with wellness-focused finds and unique gifts. The store carries skincare products, botanical beauty items, herbal teas, accessories, and giftable products that feel more personal than something pulled from a generic online search. Browsing in person makes it easy to discover new scents, ingredients, and products while finding items that fit individual preferences and styles.
Monmouth Health Foods | 181 Main Street, Manasquan
If you need: Vitamins, supplements, health foods, and groceries
Monmouth Health Foods is a go-to spot for groceries, snacks, and everyday wellness essentials. The store carries a wide selection of vitamins, supplements, health foods, and groceries, along with cleaning supplies and products tailored to dietary restrictions like gluten-free and dairy-free options. It’s especially helpful for anyone who wants to read labels in person and choose foods that align with specific health goals or allergies. Alongside pantry staples and better-for-you snacks, the shelves are stocked with both basics and harder-to-find specialty items and brands. With knowledgeable staff and a focus on health-conscious living, it’s a reliable local resource for everyday needs.
Ocean Grove Hardware | 51 Main Avenue, Ocean Grove
If you need: Home-improvement tools, paint, gardening supplies
Ocean Grove Hardware is the kind of neighborhood store that’s especially helpful when a home project can’t wait. The shop carries home-improvement tools, paint, gardening supplies, and other practical essentials for tackling repairs and seasonal projects. Instead of searching through pages of products online, shoppers can get exactly what they need the same day and get advice from knowledgeable staff.
Ocean Grove Kitchen Co. | 50 Main Avenue, Ocean Grove
If you need: Kitchen accessories, housewarming gifts, cookbooks
Ocean Grove Kitchen Co. is a great place to check before ordering kitchen gadgets and gifts online. The shop carries everything from pizza cutters, aprons, knives, ice trays, and cookware to cookbooks, serving platters, wine openers, and thoughtful housewarming gifts. Shopping in person makes it easier to compare products, feel the quality, and discover items that might not have shown up in an online search. Whether outfitting a new kitchen or picking up a gift for a friend, the store offers a curated selection that’s both practical and unique.
Quinnderella’s Toys | 119 Main Street, Manasquan
If you need: Kids’ toys and gifts
Quinnderella’s Toys in Manasquan is a colorful, nostalgia-filled shop packed with toys and little surprises for kids of all ages. The shelves are stocked with everything from Pokémon cards, NeeDoh toys, books, and squishies to outdoor toys, bubbles, candy, and other kid favorites. Instead of scrolling through endless options online, it’s easy to browse in person and find something instantly fun and gift-worthy. The mix of hands-on toys and creative play items makes it a go-to for birthdays, rainy-day treats, and last-minute gifts.
Reynolds Garden Shop | 201 E Bay Avenue, Manahawkin
If you need: Garden furniture, seasonal decorations, landscaping accessories
Reynolds Garden Shop in Manahawkin is a go-to destination for anyone looking to refresh an outdoor space or add seasonal charm to a home. The shop carries plants, garden furniture, landscaping accessories, and seasonal decorations, making it easy to find pieces that fit specific spaces and styles. The ever-changing inventory also means there’s always something new to discover throughout the year.
Replenish Refills | 658 Cookman Avenue, Asbury Park
If you need: Cleaning supplies, personal care items, coffee, legumes, pasta, spices
Instead of adding another bottle of laundry detergent, shampoo, or cleaning spray to an online shopping cart, consider stopping by Replenish Refills in Asbury Park. This low-waste refillery carries everyday essentials like cleaning supplies, laundry detergent, body wash, shampoo, toothpaste, hair brushes, coffee, pasta, legumes, and spices, all of which can be purchased using your own reusable containers. The shop’s refill model helps cut down on single-use plastic packaging while also allowing customers to buy only the amount they need. It’s a great local alternative for stocking up on household and personal care staples while supporting a small Jersey Shore business and reducing waste at the same time.
Roger’s Pet Supplies + Feed | 991 Cedar Bridge Avenue, Brick Township
If you need: Pet food, toys, and animal supplies
Whether it’s a bag of pet food, a favorite toy, a new leash and collar, or a dog bed, Roger’s Pet Supplies & Feed in Brick has the basics covered. The longtime local shop carries products for a variety of pets, making it an easy stop for routine restocks and last-minute needs alike. Shopping in person means being able to check ingredients, compare options, and leave with exactly what’s needed that day. The staff’s product knowledge is an added bonus, especially when trying something new or finding the right fit for a pet.
Vagabond Surf | 611 Cookman Avenue, Asbury Park
If you need: Surf and skate gear, wetsuits, and clothing
Vagabond Surf in Asbury Park is a go-to spot for surf and skate gear, whether it’s a new wetsuit, surfboard accessory, pair of roller skates, or coastal-inspired clothing. Shopping for gear in person makes a difference, especially when it comes to finding the right fit, sizing, and feel.
See More: An A-Z List of Local Brick-and-Mortar Hoboken Businesses to Support Every Day
Follow @thejerseyshoregirl_ on Instagram for the latest Jersey Shore updates, sign up for our weekly newsletter here that shares everything you missed each week, and check out our events calendar, which has over 40+ events weekly to peruse.
