Carli Clesmere Valentine’s Day and Galentine’s Day provide the ideal opportunity to celebrate love in all its forms. In true Jersey fashion, few things feel more fitting than a heart-shaped pie from a hometown Bergen County pizzeria, complete with melty mozzarella and classic red sauce (or gravy). From romantic dinners to friend-filled gatherings, or even a cozy solo night in, several local spots are serving heart-shaped pizzas for the holiday. Read on for a list of 9 Bergen County pizzerias offering heart-shaped pies this Valentine’s season.
Corleone’s Pizza | 205 Williams Avenue, Hasbrouck Heights
View this post on Instagram
This family-run pizza shop offers heart-shaped pies for Valentine’s and Galentine’s Day celebrations. Beyond pizza, the full menu includes a variety of hot and cold subs that locals know and love.
Read More: Sport-Famous ‘First’ Occurrences That Happened in New Jersey
Crecco’s Cafe | 649 Westwood Avenue, River Vale
Crecco’s will be making heart-shaped pizza this year for those celebrating love over cheesy bites. In addition to its pizzas, the menu also offers lighter options, including salads and vegetable dishes.
Francesca Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta | 234 Rock Road, Glen Rock
View this post on Instagram
Brothers Salvatore and Gino Reina have owned Francesca Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta in downtown Glen Rock since 2008. For Valentine’s season, the restaurant offers heart-shaped pizzas alongside its classic brick-oven pies and pasta dishes.
Franco’s Metro | 1479 Anderson Avenue, Fort Lee
Franco’s Metro in Fort Lee is a family-owned pizzeria, restaurant, and bar known locally as a classic Italian go-to. In addition to their pizza, which comes in a heart shape for Valentine’s and Galentine’s Day, they also offer a full menu of everyday dishes, including fresh seafood and pasta.
Grumpy’s Sourdough Pizza Co. | 522 Saddle River Road, Saddle Brook
This sourdough pizza spot has likely popped up on your feed thanks to recent hype, and it is serving heart-shaped pies this Valentine’s season. Beyond that, a go-to order is the sourdough garlic knots, especially with extra sauce.
Mama Rosa Pizza & Pasta | 649 Westwood Avenue, River Vale
Mama Rosa Pizza & Pasta will be making heart-shaped pizza this year for those celebrating or in need of a fun, love-inspired pizza. In addition to its pizzas, the pastas, particularly the cavatelli with broccoli dish is a must-order.
Mario’s Pizza | 132 West Pleasant Avenue, Maywood
View this post on Instagram
At Mario’s, everything is handcrafted with care, reflecting a dedication to quality and strong ties to the local community, including the love that goes into their heart-shaped pies for Valentine’s season.
Three Boys From Italy | 238 Livingston Street, Northvale
With a huge variety of pies + dishes to choose from, including their well-known Chicken Alla Vodka, Three Boys From Italy will be dishing out heart-shaped pizzas this Valentine’s season.
Vinnie’s Mootz | 356 Valley Brook Avenue, Lyndhurst
Many come for the fresh mutz and stay for the pizza. With a wide variety of pies to choose from, including their chicken Caesar pie, Vinnie’s will also be seriving heart-shaped pizzas this Valentine’s season.
See More: Where to Play Pickleball in Hoboken
Follow @thebergencountygirl on Instagram for the latest Bergen County updates, sign up for our email list here that shares everything you missed each week, and check out our events calendar, which has over 30+ events weekly to peruse.
