Everyone at some point needs a quick bite to eat, a convenient option that isn’t fast food. That’s why sandwiches are a quintessential beach food. Whether it’s a traditional sub on a classic roll, or something special like a focaccia-based panini, finding a go-to reliable sandwich shop is a necessity. We compiled a list that will guide you in discovering the best sandwich shops — no sorry PB+Js to be found here. Keep reading for a list of the best delis, markets, and restaurants to grab a sandwich at the Jersey Shore.
2nd Ave Sandwich Shop | 3620 NJ-35, Lavallette
The 2nd Ave Sandwich Shop is the place for those who crave breakfast no matter the time, as it serves breakfast sandwiches all day. This Normandy Beach sandwich shop has traditional subs + sandwiches, specialty sandwiches, and fun wraps. For anyone with a sweet tooth, 2nd Ave Sandwich Shop has baked goods to pick up as a good treat after the sandwich.
Beckman’s Deli | 704 10th Avenue, Belmar
View this post on Instagram
Beckman’s Deli is a sandwich shop located in Belmar that serves up classic childhood favorites. It has everything from grilled cheese to cheesesteaks, paninis, and wraps. FYI, this deli has bonus features such as using Boar’s Head deli meats for its cold subs and having fun breakfast wrap options.
Read More: A Guide to Jersey Shore Restaurants Open Late
Bennie’s Bread + Italian Market | 1159 Asbury Avenue, Ocean City
View this post on Instagram
Bennie’s Bread is an Italian bakery that has been a go-to for sandwiches in Ocean City since 1957. This long-standing cafe serves hot + cold sandwiches made to order on its Bennie’s 9″ hoagie roll, which is freshly baked in-house. Besides its wide range of sandwich options, Bennie’s Bread also has homemade deli salads, which are a good side option. Customers can also add broccoli rabe, roasted red peppers, or long hot peppers to any sandwich for two dollars each.
Berg’s Smoked Meat + Poutine | 1405 Main Street, Belmar
View this post on Instagram
Berg’s Smoked Meat + Poutine is the spot for those looking for a Montreal-style pastrami sandwich. For this specialty sandwich, Berg’s takes beef brisket and dry-cures it with 12 different spices for 21 days; after that, it is smoked and then steamed and sliced to order. Besides the Montreal-style pastrami sandwich, Berg’s also pays homage to Montreal with its authentic poutine, which can be added as a side to any sandwich for six dollars.
Bing’s Beach House Deli | 222 Main Street, Avon-By-The-Sea
View this post on Instagram
Bing’s Beach House Deli describes itself as the location where the locals eat. It has takeout, delivery, and catering options. While it’s known for its pork roll sandwich, customers can also grab all kinds of cold and hot wraps, subs, and sandwiches. Bing’s Beach House is a fitting choice for a quick breakfast as it has a mixture of classic breakfast sandwiches.
DJ’s Delights Deli + Catering | 620 Mattison Avenue, Asbury Park
DJ’s Delights Deli + Catering has its shop in downtown Asbury Park. DJ’s believes breakfast is important, so egg sandwich variations are endless here. JSG loves The Hangover, which is egg, sausage, two slices of bacon, two pork rolls, a hash brown, and cheese. After breakfast, DJ’s also has classic deli sandwiches, specialty sandwiches, wraps, cheesesteaks, chicken or meatball parm, and grilled paninis.
Frank’s Deli + Restaurant | 1406 Main Street, Asbury Park
Frank’s Deli + Restaurant has been a staple luncheonette in Asbury Park since 1960. It has an old-school, welcoming vibe inside that locals love. Frank’s Deli + Restaurant is known for its overstuffed club + deli sandwiches, but it is especially popular for its roast + corned beef and pastrami.
G’s Cheesesteaks | 713 Arnold Avenue, Point Pleasant
View this post on Instagram
G’s Cheesesteaks is the location to visit for those who are craving a cheesesteak in Point Pleasant. It has different cheesesteak variations with various toppings and cheeses. G’s also serves up other options of chicken cheesesteaks, such as buffalo, chipotle, or honey BBQ. Customers can add extra meat for three dollars and extra cheese for two dollars to any sandwich.
Grandma’s Cheese Cafe | 612 2nd Avenue, Long Branch
Grandma’s Cheese Cafe is the place to visit for those who love paninis and a pretty aesthetic. Not only does this spot have a build-your-own panini option, but it also has different bread options like ciabatta bread, pita, or baguettes. Grandma’s Cheese Cafe includes its Grandma’s Original Cheese on its sandwiches, a specialty-made Middle-Eastern string cheese that is a generational recipe.
Hoagitos | 807 Belmar Plaza, Belmar
View this post on Instagram
Hoagitos is a sandwich shop that is part of the recent trend of mixing fast food convenience with high-quality fare. It specializes in home-roasted meats, cooked-to-order “Hoagitos” + sliders, or mini-subs made with care, and it is a quick pick-up for those in a rush. It has fried chicken sandwiches, breakfast sandwiches, and fun options like its Spicy Chicken Parm, part of its Hoagitos lineup.
Joe Leone’s Centro Market | 113 Main Street, Manasquan
View this post on Instagram
Joe Leone’s Centro Market is in the center of downtown Manasquan. Locals love its gourmet sandwiches made with Italian meats, handmade mozzarella, and fresh bread. The bread options here include focaccia, Neapolitan wraps, and baguettes. Customers can personalize sandwiches by choosing from cheeses, sauces, and toppings.
Josie’s Good Eats | 314 Main Street, Bradley Beach
View this post on Instagram
Josie’s Good Eats serves traditional deli-style sandwiches that are made to comfort its Bradley Beach customers. All of its sandwiches are made to order with its brick oven bread. Josie’s Good Eats’ menu features classic turkey, roast beef, Italian, and tuna sandwiches, but it also has specialty sandwich options that have fried or grilled proteins topped with options like avocado, bacon, or peppers.
Mike’s Giant Submarines | 700 8th Avenue, Belmar
View this post on Instagram
Mike’s Giant Submarines, not to be confused with the chain Jersey Mike’s, is a sandwich shop that serves subs and wraps in Belmar. As its name suggests, the submarines have a shock factor with their large size. Mike’s Giant Submarines has all the traditional deli meats + cheeses for its sandwiches, and visitors can wrap any sub.
Mugsy’s Mercantile | 629 Arnold Avenue, Point Pleasant Beach
View this post on Instagram
Mugsy’s Mercantile serves sandwiches made with love that customers can grab and go to Point Pleasant. Mugsy’s Mercantile also sells its “Sando Specials,” which contain specialty sandwiches that are part of its greatest hits of customer requests. Mugsy’s updates its website and Instagram with the sandwich menu specials.
Neil’s Kitchen | 126 West End Court, Long Branch
View this post on Instagram
Neil’s Kitchen has received numerous accolades for its sandwiches, including being awarded best sub in Monmouth County in 2017 by NJ.com. It serves up cold, hot, and specialty subs in various flavors. A sub can be substituted for white or wheat wraps, hard rolls, or sliced white, wheat, or rye bread. FYI: All sandwiches and subs come with pickles and macaroni salad.
Richard’s Deli | 155 Brighton Avenue, Long Branch
View this post on Instagram
Richard’s Deli has oversized sandwiches and deli specialties. It has sub + classic sammies — customers can pick their bread, ask for it grilled or soft, and personalize the toppings and dressings. Richard’s Deli also has wraps presses — like quesadillas, adult grilled cheese, paninis, and signature sandwiches. JSG is a fan of the fact that all wraps, sandwiches, and paninis come with its homemade potato chips.
The Speakeatery | 705 Cookman Avenue, Asbury Park
The Speakeatery is a fun sandwich shop located in Asbury Park. Its Wake + Bake section of the menu contains egg, sausage, pork roll, burger, or shrimp sandwiches served on different types of bread, such as flour tortillas, round rolls, or biscuits. There is also the BYO Egg Sandwich, which allows customers to pick two eggs and bread selections. For lunch, it has specialty sandwiches that are hard to find at other locations.
See More: A Guide to Food Trucks in Hoboken + Jersey City
Sub of a Beach | 642 NJ-88, Point Pleasant
Sub of a Beach is a casual sandwich eatery located in Point Pleasant. It has plenty of breakfast options, but JSG loves having a whole section dedicated to biscuit-based breakfast sandwiches. Sub of a Beach also has hot and cold subs and store-made pasta salad, which is a good side option.
Tom Bailey’s Market | 1323 3rd Avenue, Spring Lake
View this post on Instagram
Tom Bailey’s Market is in downtown Spring Lake. It specializes in New York-style deli sandwiches and has a prime butcher shop. Tom Bailey’s Market serves breakfast sandwiches that customers can build to make their own, as well as a variety of chicken cutlet sandwiches, specialty sandwiches, and wraps.
Vito’s Sandwiches + Specialties | 2304 NJ-35, Ortley Beach
View this post on Instagram
Vito’s Sandwiches + Specialities has many deli meats and homemade sauces. It serves Italian sandwiches in an authentic yet modern way, including cold sandwiches and signature sandwiches. Vito’s steak sandwiches have an option for ribeye or sliced chicken breast.
