Home » 13 Jersey Shore Restaurants Serving Heart-Shaped Pizza This Valentine’s Day

13 Jersey Shore Restaurants Serving Heart-Shaped Pizza This Valentine’s Day

by Jessica Norton
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Love is in the air, and so is the aroma of freshly baked pizzas at the Jersey Shore. This Valentine’s season, local pizzerias are serving up a fun and creative twist on a beloved classic. From regular cheese and pepperoni toppings to garlic knot crusts and allergy-friendly options, these charming, heart-shaped pizza creations have become a popular way to add a little extra romance to the holiday. For a solo treat, date night, family meal, work party, or a Galentine’s girl dinner, these fun and festive heart-shaped pizzas are a lighthearted — and delicious — way to celebrate Valentine’s Day or Galentine’s Day. Read on to learn more about where to get heart-shaped pizza at the Jersey Shore for 2025.

heart-shaped-pizza-jersey-shore-nj

Asbury Park

Joe’s Rotisseria | 504 Main Street

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Joe’s Rotisseria (@joes_rotisseria)

Joe’s Rotisseria on Main Street in Asbury Park is known for its one-of-a-kind pizza creations. Its menu includes unique flavors and wild combinations. It is home to the “triple threat,” which is a calzone, garlic knots, and pizza, all in one. It’s no surprise that Joe’s Rotisseria will be going all-out for Valentine’s Day, serving up a heart-shaped pizza for the season of love.

Read More: Valentine’s Day + Galentine’s Day 2025: Events at the Jersey Shore

Brick

Federico’s Pizza | 2134 NJ-88

Federico’s Pizza is a family-run pizza joint with  a full menu featuring an array of pies, subs, and Italian dishes. Plus, the local favorite spot has gluten-free options to those with food intolerances, restrictions, or allergies. Federico’s will be serving heart-shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day 2025. Federico’s is available for takeout, delivery, and on-site dining.

Highlands

Franny’s Pizzeria + Restaurant | 279 Bay Avenue

Franny’s Pizzeria + Restaurant in Highlands is an easygoing, family-operated eatery known for its pizza with creative toppings, as well as pasta, meat, and seafood options. The casual, beach pizzeria has vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options on its menu. Customers are welcome to dine in, carry out, or choose delivery. Franny’s will serve up heart-shaped pizzas for Valentine’s Day this year.

Manahawkin

Fusaro Pizza + Pasta | 31 North Main Street

Fusaro Pizza and Pasta — located in Manahawkin, New Jersey — is known for its authentic Italian cuisine. In celebration of Valentine’s Day, it will have special heart-shaped pizzas available for pre-order, allowing customers to share a unique and romantic meal with their loved ones.

Middletown

Pasquale’s Pizzeria III | 147 Cherry Tree Farm Road

Pasquale’s Pizzeria III in Middletown is a casual pizzeria that dishes up Brooklyn-style pies. Pasquale’s is also known for having delicious, freshly prepared Italian dinners and a variety of gluten-free and vegan options. The pizzeria will serve  special heart-shaped pizzas for Valentine’s Day.

Neptune

Maurizio’s Pizzeria | 2200 NJ-66

Maurizio’s Pizzeria in Neptune has a menu with a wide variety of mouth-watering pizzas, as well as an array of appetizers, salads, hot and cold subs, pasta, veal, chicken, and seafood dishes. In celebration of Valentine’s Day, Maurizio’s is serving up heart-shaped pizzas, allowing patrons to surprise loved ones with a festive and delicious treat.

Ocean

Luigi’s Square Pizza | 809 West Park Avenue

Luigi’s Square Pizza is a cozy pizzeria nestled in Ocean, New Jersey. It is known for serving up delicious square-shaped pizzas with a variety of toppings. Both Luigi’s Square Pizza in Ocean and its other location — Luigi’s Famous Pizza in Lincroft — will serve  heart-shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day in 2025.

Tramonto’s Pizza | 3311 Sunset Avenue

Tramonto’s is a laid-back pizzeria serving up a menu of Detroit-style, deep-dish, and upside-down pies and paninis. Tramonto’s will have heart-shaped pizza on its menu for the season of love.

Ocean Grove

Tinos Artisan Pizza Co. | 50 Main Avenue

Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co. in Ocean Grove is celebrated for its all-natural, organic ingredients and artisanal pizzas. The quaint, beach town restaurant will serve heart-shaped pizza from February 10th to the 14th upon request.

Point Pleasant

Oakwood Pizza | 2708 Bridge Avenue

Oakwood Pizza, the Point Pleasant Pizza joint known for its cheesesteaks and slices, plus wings, hot dogs, subs, and more, will serve heart-shaped pizzas for Valentine’s Day. Oakwood has gluten-free and vegan options for those with dietary restrictions.

Toms River

Linda’s Pizza | 902 Fischer Boulevard

Linda’s Pizza is a local eatery with a variety of pizzas, pasta dishes, salads, and appetizers. Linda’s will be serving up heart-shaped pizzas made with love for the Valentine’s season this year.

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza | 1 NJ-37

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by @mangia.nj

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza is a family-owned eatery that serves delicious brick oven pizzas and authentic Italian cuisine. The Toms River, Shrewsbury, and Jackson locations will all have heart-shaped pizza on their menus to celebrate Valentine’s Day. Mangia’s will also have a garlic knot-crusted heart-shaped pizza option available at all locations.

See More: 15 Unique Valentine’s Day Date Ideas in the Hoboken + Jersey City Area

Wall

Attilio’s Pizza + Restaurant | 1825 Route 35

Attilio’s Pizza + Restaurant in Wall is a casual, family-run pizzeria that serves classic Italian meals. Attilio’s will have classic heart-shaped pizzas as well as heart-shaped Nutella pizza topped with strawberries for both dine-in or takeout from February 10th to the 15th.

read more food button

also appears in

0 comment