Jenna Giustino When it comes to the Jersey Shore, we often automatically think about towns like Asbury Park, Wildwood, LBI, and more. There are so many neighborhoods tucked in between that often get overlooked, and one of those areas is Keyport. In recent years, it’s grown, and there are so many restaurants, cafes, boutiques, and more worth checking out. Keep reading for our guide to Keyport’s hidden gems.
A Family Treasure | 13 West Front Street
A Family Treasure is an antique store. It has a collection of antiques and collectibles, old and new. JSG recommends stopping in if you are in the mood to shop a large collection of vintage jewelry, watches, lamps, mirrors, plates, furniture, records, phones, vintage clothing, and more.
Read More: A Guide to Spring + Summer Flea Markets at the Jersey Shore
3BR Distillery | 7 Main Street
3BR Distillery makes craft spirits with a focus on bold flavors. The distillery features a Soviet-kitsch tasting room, a sleek cocktail bar, and cozy lounge areas, making it a fun option for date night or an evening with friends. Pro tip: 3BR encourages guests to order in from local eateries for delivery to the distillery while sipping cocktails.
Broad Street Diner | 83 Broad Street
Broad Street is Keyport’s go-to diner. There are plenty of comfort-food plates, and the retro aesthetic feels nostalgic. Broad Street’s menu highlights include breakfast served all day and, for lunch, we suggest the Jersey Shore Fried Combo.
Drew’s Bayshore Bistro | 44 East Front Street
View this post on Instagram
Drew’s Bayshore Bistro is a BYOB Cajun restaurant. The menu includes shrimp and grits, smoked short rib mac and cheese, and more. As an appetizer, JSG recommends trying the crawfish empanada. PS: Joelle from our team SWEARS by this spot.
Keyport Fishery | 150 West Front Street
Keyport Fishery is a seafood market. It’s a classic takeout spot for soups, sandwiches, platters, and fried fish by the pound. The made-to-order menu features freshly prepared seafood overlooking the Raritan Bay, and catering and a food truck are available for private events.
Keyport Funhouse | 81 Broad Street, Keyport
View this post on Instagram
Keyport Funhouse is a boutique and drinkery. There’s a selection of designer clothes, jewelry, and fun gifts to shop for. Keyport Funhouse has indoor and outdoor lounges, free wifi, and homemade chocolates, NY-style egg creams, teas, coffees, lemonades, and dirty sodas to enjoy before or after shopping.
Keyport Princess | 1 American Legion Drive
The Keyport Princess is a boat that offers fishing charters and whale-watching trips. The Keyport Princess hosts daily fishing trips, spring + fall tripper fishing, and magic hour (four-hour evening fishing trips). The boat also runs Raritan Bay weekend cruises, including New York Harbor cruises, dolphin and whale watching, three-hour Raritan Bay cruises, and four-hour Staten Island cruises.
Keyport Waterfront Park | American Legion Drive
Keyport Waterfront Park is on Raritan Bay. It features a gazebo, fishing pier, and boat ramp. FYI: There’s plenty of free parking, and the park is a prime location for sunset.
Lenora’s Cafe | 18 W Front Street
Lenora’s is a casual cafe. The menu has plenty of breakfast items, and for lunch and dinner, there are paninis, wraps, burgers, and more. Lenoa’s is also available for pick up and delivery.
Lucy’s Mexican American Restaurant | 38 Broad Street
Lucy’s is a Mexican-American restaurant. Menu highlights include flautas, chicken fajitas, and chimichanga. JSG Tip: Come hungry – Lucy’s portions are massive.
McDonagh’s Pub + Restaurant | 2 West Front Street
McDonagh’s Pub is known for its bar-style food, cold beer, and entertainment lineup. The pub has two bars, two stages, and 25+ TVs, making it a hub for a good time in Keyport. JSG Tip: McDonagh’s Pub’s brick-oven pizza is a must-try.
Moxie Coffee + Bakehouse | 24 Broad Street
View this post on Instagram
Moxie is an artisan coffee shop and scratch bakery. It’s a locally sourced, organic ingredient spot. Moxie’s grand opening is coming soon. To keep updated, click here.
Nature’s Plate Vegan Cafe | 15 Main Street
Nature’s Plate, a vegan cafe, has standout options like its buffalo seitan mac + cheese and the BLT. There are also power bowls, burgers, and smoothies. Nature’s Plate juices are also a must-try.
Nemo | 27 West Front Street
View this post on Instagram
Nemo is an Asian fusion restaurant. The menu includes everything from sushi to sesame chicken to rice and noodles. Nemo is also available for online ordering.
Stress Free Body | 52 West Front Street
Stress Free Body hosts yoga, meditation, Reiki, and massage classes. The studio hosts various wellness events and workshops. To view Stress Free Body’s classes and schedule, click here.
Sun Moon Studio | 29B West Front Street
View this post on Instagram
Sun Moon is an art studio. It hosts various artistic workshops and events for people of all levels. Sun Moon Studio creates a space where individuals can connect and
exchange ideas.
The Parlour | 8 Main Street
The Parlor is a one-of-a-kind destination shop and experimental space. Think everything from curiosities, oddities, magickal items, and ghost tours. The Parlour often hosts events, workshops, and more – to keep updated, click here.
Up The Creek Tavern + Paddle Bar | 350 West Front Street
Up The Creek Tavern + Paddle Bar is known for its happy hour and neighborhood vibes. The bar menu features all the classics, and the restaurant has views of Matawan Creek and the marina. Up The Creek Tavern + Paddle Bar also has a pool table, completing the fun atmosphere.
See More: Summer House Reunion Watch Parties Happening in New Jersey
Follow @thejerseyshoregirl_ on Instagram for the latest Jersey Shore updates, sign up for our weekly newsletter here that shares everything you missed each week, and check out our events calendar, which has over 40+ events weekly to peruse.