When tracking down authentic Italian cuisine in New Jersey, finding a great spot is hardly a challenge. Annabella’s House of Mozzarella earns a place on our list of must-try Italian spots in Bergen County — and we’re pretty sure even Tony Soprano would give it the stamp of approval. Located at 900 Paterson Plank Road in East Rutherford, Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is the ultimate destination for anyone in Bergen County craving those old-school authentic Italian flavors and, of course, some fresh mozzarella. Read on to learn more about Annabella’s House of Mozzarella, a beloved Bergen County spot that’s been a staple in the area for 21 years.
All About the Martini
While martinis are a classic cocktail, they can become somewhat repetitive. That’s where the team behind the bar at Annabella’s House of Mozzarella comes in, shaking up the martini game with something totally unexpected: the Mozzarella Martini (or as it’s called on the menu, the “Mozzy Martini”). A blend of mozzarella water and vodka creates this special drink, giving it a soft, somewhat savory feeling that’s a whole new way to experience a martini. For an extra touch, the bartenders top it with fresh tomato and a mini cheese ball. For both seasoned cocktail drinkers or those simply in search of something new, the Mozzy Martini brings a modern flair to a beloved classic.
BG’s thoughts: The Mozzy Martini might not be our favorite cocktail ever, but it’s still worth trying at least once. Next time at Annabella’s House of Mozzarella, we would want to explore more of the martini list, like the Limoncello-Tini or the Colada-Tini.
Read More: The Coziest Restaurants in Bergen County, New Jersey
Inside Annabella’s House of Mozzarella
Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is on a quiet road in East Rutherford, just a short drive from MetLife Stadium. Once entering, guests encounter the distinct aroma of Italian goodies; next to the door, a mini grocery section overflows with kinds of pasta, sauces (or “gravy” — but we’ll save that debate for another time), and various other Italian treats. At the front of the space is the deli counter, where one can order sandwiches or browse the cheeses, crackers, and all sorts of Italian delicacies.
The bar is past the deli area — where bartenders shake up cocktails while preparing fresh, homemade mozzarella throughout the day. We stopped by around 6PM, and the man behind the counter was still pulling it by hand. The last section of the restaurant is the dining area, which is roomy and teeming with charming Italian novelties. The atmosphere is undeniably nostalgic, from vintage black-and-white films playing on the TVs to the soft echoes of Frank Sinatra sailing through the speakers. No flashy gimmicks here, just an old-school vibe that transports guests to another time. Welcoming smiles greet customers as soon as they enter the dining space, courtesy of the friendly team.
What to Savor at Annabella’s: Menu Highlights
Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is a destination for all meals, from sunrise to sunset. Whether stopping by for breakfast, lunch, dinner, or a sweet treat to end the day, this Italian gem has it all. Twenty-one years of experience allows the team at Annabella’s House of Mozzarella to pack each dish with authentic Italian flavors that instantly transport one to the warmth and comfort of Grandma’s kitchen. Since a lot is happening at Annabella’s House of Mozzarella, here’s a breakdown of the menu(s):
- Breakfast: This is served daily from 8AM to 11AM, with a smaller menu. One can find egg sandwiches on ciabatta rolls (no bagels found here), hearty omelets, and even Italian-style pancakes. Best of all, all breakfast items cost under $13.
- Lunch: One can swing by the deli, order right from the counter, sit at a table in the back, or grab it to-go and revel in the pure satisfaction of tearing into the sub wrapper in the car. A wide variety of subs fills the lunch menu. Some standouts are the Carmine’s Jr., featuring prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, and broccoli rabe, or the Capo Di Tutti Capi, which comes with prosciutto capicolla, sopressata, mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, and roasted peppers. For those looking for something lighter, there are a few salad options that are easily customizable with protein and mozzarella cheese. Prices vary, but most lunch items are under $20.
- Dinner: The menu is thoughtfully categorized into Spuntini (small bites), Contorni (side dishes), Pasta, Insalata (salads), Minestra (soup), Pollo (chicken), Pesce (fish), Bistecca (steak), and Pasta Sides. Dinner prices are more expensive, but the portions are huge, making it easily worth it.
BG’s Order
- The Mozzarella Plate with grape tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, and roasted peppers — the mozzarella lives up to the hype.
- House salad with chicken — veggies are super fresh.
- Seafood manicotti made with Grandma Lizzy’s signature manicotti crepes — the sauce is ideal for dunking table-side bread.
- Annabella’s World-Famous Cheesecake — one slice is enough to share between 2-3 people.
Fun Events
Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is an experience. Just when things couldn’t get any better here…BADA BING, regular entertainment, and fun events keep the place alive and buzzing. It’s truly a one-stop spot for food + fun. Every week, there are different musical performances for diners to enjoy while they eat, or for those who feel like getting up and dancing. Incidental Contact, Brothers Benjamin, a Sinatra-themed evening, and Cabaret Night are among this month’s lineup. A larger event hosted by Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is Paisan Con. This celebration of Italian heritage and pop culture has a packed schedule of fun activities, including live performances, celebrity meet-and-greets, delicious Italian cuisine, distinctive vendors, and plenty of other Italian-inspired fun.
See More: Your Guide to Buying Gourmet Cheese in Hoboken + Jersey City
Hours
Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is open daily for dine-in and takeout. The hours are Monday through Wednesday 8AM-9PM, Thursday 8AM-10PM, Friday + Saturday 8AM-11PM, and on Sundays, operating hours are a bit shorter from 8AM-3PM.
The Best Bergen County, NJ Spas for a Self-Care Day
Sometimes, a reset is just what’s needed, but when a getaway isn’t an option, a visit to a local Bergen County spa and a little self-care can work wonders. Spas provide an escape to soothe muscles, rejuvenate skin with luxurious treatments, recover from a girls’ night out, or simply unwind and melt away stress and anxieties (because, well, life can be a lot). From steamy saunas to indulgent head spa treatments and full days of relaxation, this roundup features luxurious spas and spa treatments in Bergen County that provide the ultimate spa experience.
490 LAB | 38 River Edge Road, River Edge
View this post on Instagram
This wellness spot focuses on health and longevity and is backed by the latest clinical research and medical evidence. The cold plunges here are a BG favorite, available for 15-, 30-, or 60-minute sessions.
Beyond Day Spa | 20 Prospect Avenue #902, Hackensack
View this post on Instagram
Beyond Day Spa has a variety of services to choose from, including facials, hair removal, hair + nail services, massages, body + eyelash treatments, and non-surgical cosmetic treatments. There are also monthly specials to take advantage of.
Read More: 10 Best Boutiques in Bergen County, New Jersey
BRC Day Spa | 24-20 Broadway, Fair Lawn
BRC Day Spa prides itself on its website, saying, “Welcome to Luxury.” This co-ed spa has a range of relaxing experiences, including a swimming pool, hydro massage, cryotherapy, cold plunge, infrared sauna, Himalayan salt room, float spa, and traditional sauna.
CGI Holistic Fitness + Spa | 111 Homans Avenue, Closter
View this post on Instagram
For over 26 years, CGI has been serving the Bergen County community. In addition to its spa services, the facility also features a holistic healing center, a body + brain center, corporate wellness programs, an ionized pool, locker rooms with saunas, a taorobics studio, and a gym—all under one roof.
Fountain Spa | 1150 NJ-17, Ramsey + 10 Riverside Square Mall, Hackensack
The Fountain Spa has two locations in Bergen County, one in Hackensack and the other in Ramsey. It has everything needed to unwind, relax, and feel pampered. From steam rooms and cozy robes with slippers (BG’s favorite part) to whirlpools, facial + body spa packages, waxing, nail services, and multiple lounges, it’s a one-stop destination for all things pampering.
Massage Luxe | 327 Franklin Avenue, Wyckoff
View this post on Instagram
Massage Luxe presents customers with nine different massage options, ranging from Swedish and prenatal to relaxing couples massages. In addition to massages, the spa has a variety of facial + waxing services. A top pick is the hydrating facial, an ideal choice for getting the skin ready for summer.
Mindful Waters | 240 Pegasus Avenue Unit 102, Northvale
Mindful Waters provides a luxurious, relaxing, and rejuvenating wellness experience using a science-backed, eco-friendly approach. It features a one-of-a-kind water bar and a variety of wellness services like cold therapy, vibration therapy, float therapy, and infrared therapy.
New Place Organic Day Spa | 649 Anderson Avenue, Cliffside Park
View this post on Instagram
This spot is a hidden gem in Cliffside Park. From the outside, it may not stand out, but stepping inside reveals a full spa experience. With body scrubs and wraps, couples massages, facial peels, waxing, and the trending scalp massage that’s been making waves online, this spot has a ton of options for everyone.
Padel United | 160 Broadway, Cresskill
View this post on Instagram
Padel United Sports Club is a new addition to Cresskill, providing a blend of fitness and entertainment in a sophisticated setting. Featuring state-of-the-art padel courts and a fully equipped wellness center, the club provides a range of refreshing amenities, including a sauna, steam room, cold plunge pool, hot tub, 40-foot saltwater lap pool, massage therapy technology, and more.
Paradise Spa + Sauna | 100 Linwood Plaza, Fort Lee
View this post on Instagram
This Korean bathhouse in Fort Lee is nestled within the busy Linwood Shopping Center. From skincare to spa treatments and body scrubs to the soothing warmth of saunas, this spot provides so many ways for one to have some R+R. BG pro tip: After a relaxing day, visit Hachi Sushi across the street for some rolls or sashimi, and always drizzle spicy mayo.
Ridgewood European Day Spa | 44 Franklin Avenue, Ridgewood
Ridgewood European Day Spa, also known as RDS, provides a range of services, including facials, professional exfoliators, massage therapy, clinical treatments, waxing, and spa packages. A standout choice is the Sea C Spa treatment, an age-defying skincare service created to diminish visible signs of aging and rejuvenate the skin for a more youthful + bright appearance.
Soha Spa | 480 Boulevard, Garfield
View this post on Instagram
Soha Organic Day Spa presents a variety of services, including body treatments, foot spas, and various facial options. Couples can enjoy relaxation and quality time together with specially curated experiences. BG loves the Swedish couples’ massage, especially with hot stones for additional cozy warmth.
SoJo Spa Club | 660 River Road, Edgewater
Photo Credit: SoJo Spa Club
SoJo Spa creates the feeling of being far from Jersey. This expansive, multi-level spa in Edgewater provides services like heated outdoor baths, cozy saunas, mouthwatering bites at the food court, and world-class massages. BG pro tip: Sojo also has a hotel for anyone looking to get away for the night.
The Spa at Glenpointe | 200 Frank West Burr Boulevard, Teaneck
The Spa at Glenpointe is a hidden gem in Teaneck, providing an indoor pool, a state-of-the-art gym, and post-workout wellness services. It’s an optimal spot for parents to unwind, with kids’ activities as well, making it a one-stop destination for both adults and children.
Spavia | 379 NJ-17, Ridgewood
View this post on Instagram
Spavia Ridgewood gives customers a variety of treatments tailored to their needs and preferences. Treatments include massages, body + facial treatments, eyelash extensions, tanning, mineral makeup application, and waxing. There are specialized treatments for men, making it a suitable spot for a relaxing day out with your significant other.
See More: A Guide to the Best Facials in Jersey City
King Spa | 321 Commercial Avenue, Palisades Park
At King Spa, guests can immerse themselves in Korean spa culture, enjoying a blend of holistic health and absolute relaxation. The spa has a dry sauna, wet sauna, healing room, aroma lounge, restaurant, and juice bar, providing a complete wellness experience.
